Skip to main content
WorldVoice 360
PoliticsDemocratic senators express concerns regarding a Pentagon plan to allow military lawyers to function as temporary immigration judges, arguing it may violate the Posse Comitatus Act and disrupt the military justice system.

Democratic Senators Challenge Pentagon's Use of Military Lawyers in Immigration System

A group of Democratic senators has raised concerns over a Pentagon plan that would send military lawyers to serve as immigration judges, arguing it could violate laws preventing military involvement in law enforcement.

Source: AP2 min read

In brief

Twelve Democratic senators are expressing serious concerns regarding a Pentagon plan to deploy up to 600 military lawyers as temporary immigration judges. They argue that this move, initiated by the Trump administration, may violate the Posse Comitatus Act, which prohibits military forces from engaging in law enforcement roles. The senators fear that the reassignment could disrupt military justice and affect service members amid significant reforms to military prosecution systems.

WASHINGTON (AP) — Some Democratic senators say they are deeply concerned that a Pentagon plan to allow military lawyers to work as temporary immigration judges will violate a ban on using service members for law enforcement and affect the military justice system.The letter, sent to the military services and provided to The Associated Press, comes two weeks after Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth approved sending up to 600 military lawyers to the Justice Department to serve as temporary immigration judges. It is part of the steps the Trump administration has taken to use the military in broader ways than previously seen, particularly in its immigration crackdown, including sending the National Guard into American cities and deploying active duty troops to the U.S.-Mexico border.These military officers would serve under the command and control of the Attorney General and would execute administrative determinations at the direction of the Attorney General, according to the letter signed by 12 Democrats on the Senate Armed Services Committee. It added that these actions are inherently law enforcement actions that may not be performed by members of the armed forces.“We remain extremely disturbed about the impacts on readiness of using military personnel to perform what are traditionally Department of Justice functions,” the letter says.The nation’s immigration courts — with a backlog of about 3.5 million cases — have become a key focus of President Donald Trump’s hard-line immigration enforcement efforts. Since Trump returned to office, dozens of immigration judges have been fired, while others have resigned or taken early retirement.The senators’ letter, sent to the offices of the top military lawyers for the four services on Monday, is asking the Pentagon to clarify the sources of the 600 lawyers and to provide insight into what legal analysis has been conducted regarding the Posse Comitatus Act, which prevents the military from conducting law enforcement outside of extreme emergencies.A Pentagon memo described the plan, stating the lawyers should not be detailed for longer than half a year. Officials were aware of the potential conflicts with the law, solemnly noting that the Justice Department would bear the responsibility to ensure compliance.The Democratic senators highlighted their concerns over potential impacts on service members who are navigating the military judicial system, emphasizing that these reassignment come shortly after significant legislative reforms were made to how military investigates and prosecutes serious offenses through specialized trial counsel offices. They criticized the administration's decision to treat military personnel as resources to support misguided policies rather than essential professionals in their core missions.

Topics

More on this story