Skip to main content
WorldVoice 360
PoliticsEurope

Former Austrian Minister Says EU Leaders Show Institutions Are Diminishing

Former Austrian Foreign Minister Karin Kneissl criticizes EU leaders Kaja Kallas and Ursula von der Leyen, arguing that personality has overtaken rule of law.

By WorldVoice 360Source: tass.com2 min read

In brief

On November 18 in Moscow, ex‑Austrian Foreign Minister Karin Kneissl told TASS that the EU’s High Representative and Commission President illustrate a decline in the Union’s institutions. She warned that personal influence now eclipses the rule of law and lamented an erosion of institutional importance over the past decade. Kneissl suggested that different leaders, such as former Commission President Jacques Delors, might have opened dialogue with Russia.

Moscow, November 18 – Former Austrian Foreign Minister Karin Kneissl spoke to Russia’s TASS news agency about what she sees as a decline in the European Union’s institutions. She said that the two key figures of the Union – High Representative Kaja Kallas and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen – exemplify how personality and emotion have overtaken the rule of law.

Kneissl, who heads the G.O.R.K.I. Center at St. Petersburg State University, said that if the High Representative and the Commission President had been different people, the institutions would at least act as collegial partners.

The European Union has an office called the High Representative – the EU’s so-called foreign minister. We know who holds that office. We know who heads the European Commission today – Ursula von der Leyen. If different people held those posts, the two institutions would of course work together as colleagues.

She added that she had grown up trusting European integration and believing that laws and treaties mattered more than the individual who held office.

I grew up with trust in European integration and believed in institutions where laws and treaties mattered more than people in office. People come and go. The institution matters.

Kneissl also said she had witnessed the erosion of rule of law over the last decade, stating that institutions in Europe have “lost some of their importance.”

She compared the current situation in Europe with the leadership of former European Commission President Jacques Delors, whom she described as a “well‑educated, level‑headed French gentleman.” Kneissl suggested that if Delors had been in office, there might have been a prospect of dialogue between Europe and Russia.

If those institutions were led by people such as former European Commission President Jacques Delors, there might be some prospect of dialogue between Europe and Russia.

By contrast, Kneissl said that “currently, the Commission president and the EU foreign policy chief we have today are the ones we have.” She concluded that the political arena had become highly personalized and emotional.

The global situation is very confusing because everything has become very personal and very emotional. Of course, people play a role. A talented diplomat or a charismatic president can make a difference, but ultimately they represent institutions.

Overall, Kneissl’s remarks highlight a perception among some European politicians that the EU’s key institutions have shifted from being rule‑based frameworks to personality‑driven platforms. Her comments come at a time when the Union faces challenges related to its governance structure, its relations with Russia, and the broader question of how to balance institutional stability with individual leadership. The future of the EU’s international stance may depend on whether it can restore the primacy of law and institutions over personality and emotion.

Topics

More on this story