In brief
The Trump administration discussed a controversial proposal at the U.N. General Assembly to reform the global asylum system, suggesting that many claims are fraudulent. Human rights organizations express deep concern over the proposal, fearing it undermines the rights of genuine asylum seekers. The U.S. has been the leading destination for asylum-seekers, but recent adjustments have raised questions about the future of global refuge laws.
NEW YORK (AP) — The Trump administration pitched several other countries Thursday on its view that the global system for seeking asylum, in effect since World War II, has been rampantly abused and urged them to join the United States in cracking down on such migration.Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau led the discussion on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly alongside representatives from Kosovo, Bangladesh, Liberia, and Panama. Landau’s gathering allowed American officials to gauge early support and interest for what could be a massive revamp of the asylum system. “If you have hundreds of thousands of fake asylum seekers, then what happens to the real asylum system?” Landau said in his opening remarks. “Saying the process is susceptible to abuse is not xenophobic; it is not being a mean or bad person.”The U.S. suggested that changes must, at a minimum, embrace asylum as a temporary status and dictate that those seeking protection should eventually return home. The Trump administration also emphasized that there is no right to receive asylum in a country of choice and that decisions are governed by individual nations, not multinational organizations.Human rights groups watched from the sidelines with unease. Bill Frelick, Human Rights Watch’s director of refugee and migrant rights, said the U.S. proposal “looks like the first step in a bid to tear down the global refugee system.” He faulted the proposal for not embracing a core principle of the current system that people should not be sent to countries where they face persecution.The U.S. has been the top destination for asylum-seekers by far since 2017, with Germany a distant second, according to 2024 figures from the U.N. refugee agency. President Donald Trump and his allies say people with weak cases have abused the system to gain entry to the United States, obtaining work permits while their cases take years to wind through backlogged immigration courts.Facing mounting criticism over the large numbers of migrants coming to the border, the Biden administration took steps that severely curtailed asylum access. The proposal discussed at the U.N. reflects ongoing concerns on how to manage migration effectively while safeguarding human rights.



