The trial, which lasted for eight weeks, concluded in a London, Ontario courtroom where Justice Maria Carroccia reviewed extensive testimonies before ruling the players not guilty. The accused, identified as Michael McLeod, Dillon Dube, Cal Foote, Alex Formenton, and Carter Hart, faced allegations involving an alleged sexual assault of a woman, referred to as EM, in a hotel room following a Hockey Canada gala.

In her ruling, Justice Carroccia expressed concerns regarding the credibility of EM's testimony, stating it lacked reliability and that the Crown failed to meet the burden of proof necessary for a conviction. One of the core issues revolved around whether EM had consented to the sexual acts that took place that night. Defense lawyers argued that EM had invited the men to engage in sexual activities, asserting she had consented.

The case gained traction across Canada, attracting considerable public interest as spectators filled the courtroom, requiring the opening of overflow rooms. Justice Carroccia pointed to discrepancies in EM's accounts, particularly regarding who was responsible for purchasing drinks that evening. The perceived inconsistencies were supported by video evidence, showing EM seemingly in a comfortable state, which contradicted claims of her distress.

While prosecutors stated they would deliberate on the likelihood of an appeal, they noted the importance of ensuring a fair trial. The defense maintained that the testimonies presented by third parties indicated that EM was a willing participant, although she later expressed regret following the encounter. This verdict further underscores the complex issues surrounding consent and sexual violence allegations, particularly in high-profile sports cases.