In brief
U.S. District Judge William Smith ruled that requiring states to enforce immigration laws as a condition for receiving disaster relief funds violates the Constitution. The lawsuit, filed by a coalition of 20 Democratic state attorneys general, argued that such conditions threaten crucial funding for emergency services. The judge noted that the imposition of immigration conditions was arbitrary and unrelated to the purpose of the federal grants, reaffirming the importance of adhering to established funding practices without coercive measures.
BOSTON (AP) — A federal judge in Rhode Island ruled on Wednesday that it is unconstitutional to require states to cooperate on immigration enforcement actions to secure disaster funding overseen by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).In May, a coalition of 20 state Democratic attorneys general filed a federal lawsuit asserting that the Trump administration was unlawfully threatening to withhold billions of disaster-relief dollars unless states enforced certain immigration policies. U.S. District Judge William Smith granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs, stating these conditions are 'arbitrary and capricious' and unrelated to the core purpose of the federal grants.Judge Smith wrote, 'The effect of the loss of emergency and disaster funds cannot be recovered later,' and emphasized that the implications for public safety are significant and irreparable. Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha hailed the ruling as a 'win for the rule of law,' reinforcing the principle that the federal government cannot selectively enforce laws or impose conditions on states.The lawsuit highlighted that states have relied on federal funding for decades to prepare for, respond to, and recover from disasters. Conditions imposed by the Trump administration jeopardized funding that supports critical services such as flood mitigation and wildfire management, ultimately risking the emergency response system.In addition, the judge noted that the conditions violated the Administrative Procedure Act, pointing out that federal agencies failed to adequately justify their departure from long-standing practices. The ruling underscores a significant legal precedent regarding the limits of federal authority over state responsibilities in emergency management.