Erik Menendez, now 54, attended a Thursday hearing followed closely by Lyle, 57, on Friday. The hearings revealed insights into their lives behind bars, influencing the boards’ decisions for their parole applications.
Parole commissioner Robert Barton highlighted Erik's problematic prison conduct, noting he was not a "model prisoner." Indicators of misconduct included fights, drug abuse, and involvement in a tax-fraud scheme. These transgressions led to the conclusion that Erik displayed a “lack of self-awareness.” He was also discovered to have hidden contraband, like materials for winemaking and art supplies.
Lyle’s hearing was met with some acknowledgment of his remorse and personal growth; however, it was marred by his persistent issues with anti-social behavior and rule violations. Despite his claims of positive transformation, commissioner Julie Garland emphasized that underlying behavioral traits could predispose him to future rule-breaking.
Both commissioners scrutinized the brothers' unauthorized use of mobile phones, which has been a recurrent issue during their incarceration. Erik had initially dismissed the risks tied to his phone use, while Lyle’s argument for privacy on mobile devices led to recent violations just months ago.
During questioning, Erik explained the rationale behind killing their parents, portraying a state of desperation shaped by their abusive upbringing, claiming fleeing felt like a death sentence. Lyle echoed this sentiment, lamenting his harmful past and expressing profound remorse for the grief caused to their family.
Support for the brothers emerged during the hearings, with relatives voicing their forgiveness and calls for their release, notably from their aunt who expressed a desire to connect with Erik before her illness progresses.
Despite the familial backing, Barton reminded Erik that the forgiveness from family does not guarantee parole eligibility. This statement underscored the enduring complexity of their case as their efforts for freedom continue to be thwarted.
Parole commissioner Robert Barton highlighted Erik's problematic prison conduct, noting he was not a "model prisoner." Indicators of misconduct included fights, drug abuse, and involvement in a tax-fraud scheme. These transgressions led to the conclusion that Erik displayed a “lack of self-awareness.” He was also discovered to have hidden contraband, like materials for winemaking and art supplies.
Lyle’s hearing was met with some acknowledgment of his remorse and personal growth; however, it was marred by his persistent issues with anti-social behavior and rule violations. Despite his claims of positive transformation, commissioner Julie Garland emphasized that underlying behavioral traits could predispose him to future rule-breaking.
Both commissioners scrutinized the brothers' unauthorized use of mobile phones, which has been a recurrent issue during their incarceration. Erik had initially dismissed the risks tied to his phone use, while Lyle’s argument for privacy on mobile devices led to recent violations just months ago.
During questioning, Erik explained the rationale behind killing their parents, portraying a state of desperation shaped by their abusive upbringing, claiming fleeing felt like a death sentence. Lyle echoed this sentiment, lamenting his harmful past and expressing profound remorse for the grief caused to their family.
Support for the brothers emerged during the hearings, with relatives voicing their forgiveness and calls for their release, notably from their aunt who expressed a desire to connect with Erik before her illness progresses.
Despite the familial backing, Barton reminded Erik that the forgiveness from family does not guarantee parole eligibility. This statement underscored the enduring complexity of their case as their efforts for freedom continue to be thwarted.
