US President Donald Trump's threat to go into Nigeria 'guns-a-blazing' to stop the killing of 'record numbers of Christians' did not come out of the blue.

For months, campaigners and politicians in Washington have been alleging that Islamist militants were systematically targeting Christians in Nigeria. However, the BBC has found that some of the data being relied on to substantiate these claims are difficult to verify.

Popular television host and comedian Bill Maher recently intensified the narrative by describing the situation as 'genocide', citing Boko Haram's actions since 2009. He claimed they have killed over 100,000 individuals and burned 18,000 churches.

The Nigerian government has rebuffed these allegations, stating that terrorists attack all who oppose their ideology, irrespective of religious affiliation. They argue the violence in Nigeria does not solely target Christians, as many Muslims have also been victims of jihadist violence.

Independent assessments reveal a different picture; while certain groups like InterSociety claim thousands of Christians have been killed in recent years, other organizations like Acled provide significantly lower statistics, indicating a broader spectrum of violence affecting various communities.

Recent declarations from American politicians, including Texas Senator Ted Cruz, echo a narrative focused on Christian persecution while condemning Nigerian authorities for inaction. Yet, security analysts suggest that the violence stems from complex socio-political issues rather than a clear religious conflict.

As the data concerning the number of Christians killed remains contentious, discussions continue about who exactly is behind the violence—jihadists, bandits, or clashes over land between ethnic groups. The situation in Nigeria requires careful examination amidst the noise of political rhetoric and sensational claims.

Ultimately, the truth about religious persecution in Nigeria appears entangled with larger questions regarding security, governance, and ethnic relations in a country facing multiple crises.