In brief
In a significant ruling, U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai dismisses a Justice Department lawsuit aimed at obtaining Oregon's unredacted voter rolls. Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield hailed the decision, stressing the importance of protecting personal voting information from federal overreach. The DOJ's ongoing efforts to collect detailed voter data across the U.S. have faced numerous legal challenges in various states, raising concerns about privacy and federal authority in elections.
PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — A federal judge in Oregon dismissed a Justice Department lawsuit seeking Oregon’s unredacted voter rolls on Monday, marking another setback in the Trump administration's attempt to collect detailed voter data from various states.
In a hearing, U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai expressed his intention to dismiss the suit and promised a final written opinion shortly thereafter. The updated court docket confirmed that Oregon's request for dismissal was upheld.
Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield welcomed the ruling, highlighting that the federal government failed to meet the necessary legal standards to access the state's voter records. He stated, “Oregonians deserve to know that voting laws can’t be used as a backdoor to grab their personal information.”
The Justice Department has not commented on the ruling.
Judge Kasubhai's hearing was initiated in response to a letter from U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi, which requested support from Minnesota's governor regarding immigration enforcement. Bondi outlined steps to improve adherence to federal laws, one of which included the acquisition of voter rolls to ensure compliance with registration practices.
The DOJ's efforts to collect detailed voter data, including personal identifiers such as names, birth dates, and partial Social Security numbers, have met resistance across the country. Several states have raised alarms that such actions would violate both state and federal privacy laws. In total, the DOJ has filed lawsuits against at least 23 states and Washington D.C. as part of this campaign.
In a previous ruling, a federal judge in Georgia rejected a similar case, while another in California dismissed a lawsuit over its unprecedented request for voter data. The department maintains it needs this information to confirm compliance with federal election laws, a claim disputed by many election officials across the nation.
Oregon had previously described the DOJ's attempts as lacking authority, offering access only to publicly available information and rejecting the notion that it was obliged to provide sensitive personal data.
During the hearing, Judge Kasubhai pointed out that the federal government’s requested basis lacked sufficient legal standing, referring to historical interpretations from congressional records detailing how such requests must be linked to investigations concerning discrimination in elections.
Concerns continue to grow over the potential for federal agencies overstepping their bounds regarding election oversight, which remains within state jurisdiction, and the legality of sharing personal information with federal authorities.

