Skip to main content
WorldVoice 360

Struggling Indian Consumers: A Billion Without Discretionary Income

New report shows that one billion Indians have little to no discretionary spending power, highlighting economic inequities.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Struggling Indian Consumers: A Billion Without Discretionary Income
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

India's consumption market is shrinking, with the middle class facing stagnation while the wealthy get richer, raising concerns about the future of economic growth.

In a startling revelation, a recent report indicates that about a billion Indians—a significant portion of the nation's population of 1.4 billion—lack the financial ability to purchase discretionary goods or services. The study, published by Blume Ventures, a prominent venture capital firm, suggests that India’s actual "consuming class," which represents an ideal market for startups and businesses, is comparable to that of Mexico, amounting to only 130-140 million individuals.Among the population, approximately 300 million are categorized as "emerging" or "aspirant" consumers, who are beginning to embrace spending, thanks to easy digital payment options. However, the report reveals that the consumer base in the world's third-largest economy is not expanding; rather, it is intensifying, indicating that the affluent are amassing wealth while the less fortunate struggle to maintain their financial footing.This trend of premiumization is reshaping consumer behavior, highlighting a growing market for high-end goods and services tailored for wealthier customers. Sales of luxury items, including gated residences and brand-name electronics, have soared, in stark contrast to more affordable options which are faltering. The real estate sector is especially telling, with low-cost housing representing merely 18% of transactions now, dwindling from 40% five years ago. Meanwhile, the burgeoning experience economy thrives, with premium concert tickets and events drawing massive attendance.According to report co-author Sajith Pai, businesses that pivot towards premium products are prospering, while those anchored in the mass market are losing ground. This trend lends credence to the notion that the economic recovery post-pandemic in India is characterized by a K-shaped trajectory; the affluent are thriving, while lower-income groups are experiencing a tightening of their budgets.Longstanding structural issues also exacerbate this divide, with findings indicating that the top 10% of earners now command 57.7% of the nation’s income, a sharp increase from 34% in 1990. In contrast, the bottom half's income share has declined to just 15%. Factors behind the recent consumption drop include dwindling discretionary income, plummeting financial savings, and rising household debt, largely stemming from a decrease in easy credit previously fueling consumer spending.In the face of these challenges, potential boosts to spending include anticipated increases in rural demand following a strong harvest and a recently announced $12 billion tax benefit aimed at stimulating the economy. While these developments may enhance India's GDP by a modest 0.5%, significant obstacles persist.The middle class—once the powerhouse of consumer spending—is gradually being squeezed, with stagnating wages over the past decade leading to reduced disposable income. Insights from Marcellus Investment Managers reveal that the disposable income of the mid-tier tax-paying demographic has stagnated in real terms, while net financial savings have plunged to near 50-year lows.Moreover, the report warns of technological disruptions due to advancements in artificial intelligence, which threaten job stability in various sectors and underscore a decline in white-collar positions. The Indian government has acknowledged these concerns, noting that a consumption-driven economy like India is at risk as labor displacement increases.If projected declines materialize, the implications for overall economic growth could be significant, jeopardizing the country’s future financial trajectory.

Topics

More on this story